Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Wayne Crocker's avatar

There’s something powerful in this — bringing people back into awareness of place matters.

But I think there’s a deeper contradiction worth exploring.

If we are truly part of a watershed, a biome, a living system… then we’re not separate enough to quiz ourselves about it as if we’re outside looking in.

That framing quietly turns us into observers of something we are continuously shaping.

So the shift might be less about:

“How much do I know about this place?”

And more about:

“What is this place becoming through how I’m living in it?”

Which raises a different kind of question entirely:

Not:

“Can I answer where my water comes from?”

But:

“What am I currently doing to the system that water depends on — and what is it doing back to me?”

Because if we’re embedded, then every action is a contribution.

Every habit is a signal.

Every adjustment is a form of participation.

So maybe the real exercise isn’t answering the 30 questions.

It’s noticing, in real time:

What am I becoming within this system — and is that helping it hold together or pulling it apart?

—

I’ll expand on this in a restack — there’s more here than a comment allows.

Randy Schroeder's avatar

I had about 28. I can see how living on a regenerative farm in rural New England would put me more in touch naturally with these things. Fun and important questions though.

39 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?