Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Landon Rordam's avatar

"What they call consciousness only arrived when we invented language. Human-type consciousness requires language; and language enables consciousness. We were not fully conscious until we could think using the symbols of language."

This is a pretty bold statement to just put out there without any argument. I don't know if most consciousness researchers would agree. Language certainly flavors our consciousness -- but does it change it in a meaningful way? Or does language simply unlock our ability to express the consciousness that was always innate, both to ourselves and others?

This is especially stark compared to your earlier claim of "molecular consciousness" for Alpha Fold. There you're basically arguing for panpsychism, the idea that everything has a little bit of consciousness, that's it's basically a property like molecular forces.

But if that's the case, then why is language required for our consciousness?

Rajesh Achanta's avatar

The continuum framing is persuasive and the synthetic/artificial distinction is useful. But the language claim seems to me to have it backwards, and the contemplative traditions are the reason.

For three millennia, meditative practice across Buddhist, Vedantic, and Christian-mystical lines has pointed at exactly the opposite conclusion: that the most acute awareness arrives precisely when language falls away. Not emotion, not reflex — awareness, lucid and self-present, in the gap between thoughts. The whole discipline of Vipassana or Zen is the deliberate quieting of the symbolic layer to reach what sits underneath it. If language were constitutive of consciousness, these traditions would have found silence empty. They found the opposite.

This also reframes the LLM question. We read consciousness into AI because it produces fluent sentences and we are built to read intention into sentences which is Anil's point. The fluency persuades us. But fluency is the most anthropomorphisable surface there is. The hard question isn't whether something that speaks like us has a mind. It's whether mind requires speech at all and the people who went looking most rigorously, by sitting in silence, came back saying no.

Which leaves your continuum intact, but rearranged: language may be a particular flavour of human consciousness rather than its precondition. The deaf, the aphasic, the meditator, the infant — all conscious, none dependent on words for the awareness itself.

23 more comments...

Ready for more?